Comments on: Nokia N97 vs Sony Ericsson XPERIA X1

By: AK

AK — Sat, 09 Jan 2010 09:43:40 +0000

Hey guys ,

pls inform me too when a consensus is reached …….till that time i am happy with a LG MOBILE.

LOL

HAPPY NEW YEAR TO U ALL !

By: seclub

seclub — Sun, 18 Oct 2009 21:06:46 +0000

I think both phones are quite good, at the moment I have the N95 and am thinking which one to take and most probably it will be the x1… I’m sick of this symbian because it’s so limited it totally embarrassed me – you get word, excel and power point but that was it. And some lousy games but that’s not what I’m looking for. Emails are slow and ugly compared to mobile outlook, battery has to be recharged every day no matter what you do and the GPS takes 5 mins untill it finds my position. I have the feeling if I go for the N97 I will be disappointed again, and recently I tried Windows Mobile 6 on another device and it was a lot more user-friendlier. Another thing about the Nokia N-series is the wifi – the receiver is so slow and doesn’t connect to a network which isn’t in a couple of meters from me…. I have a HP iPAQ rx1950 which is a year older and does a lot better than the n95. And about the pictures – I don’t believe even one of us prints them, they’re only in the phone, so for me there ain’t such a big difference between 3.2 and 5 mega pixel.

By: Shifat

Shifat — Thu, 15 Oct 2009 16:38:40 +0000

I think you guys dont know that N97 has 128MB RAM, 434 MHz processor while Xperia X1 has 256 RAM, 528 MHz and 256 MHz 2 core processor with 3D graphics accelerator from ATI.
Who wins in performance?

By: Kissmuss

Kissmuss — Thu, 03 Sep 2009 16:07:45 +0000

Sony is still the best, Why? Because price remains while Nokia’s price gets cheaper and cheaper until you are already left behind. I think thats one thing you should know as a user.

By: Steve Joe

Steve Joe — Fri, 21 Aug 2009 13:08:21 +0000

that is great, valuable ideas, I have xperial x1i 4 a month but never experience any problems.
the only thing wants to get nework the support net service, ggooo, sony Steve Juba Southern.
i N97 is boring toooo – xpensive.

By: Bashar

Bashar — Tue, 11 Aug 2009 01:48:54 +0000

with all your respect Ian, I believe you just made a good bed time story and you don’t own both devices. Please just grow up. I agree with kleber. Don’t you get it guys? It’s not about the features of the phone, its about quality and reliability. I keep saying this on and on but people are not smart enough to understand. Although nokia phones give us the best features, they also give us the worst quality! It’s like owning a very fast car with good looks. However, when it comes to handling and good quality its terrible. Therefore, I would go with a sony ericsson on a nokia any day any time! Sorry if you don’t like what I say, but you can some homework considering this matter and I’m sure you will understand where I am coming from.

By: guiliano

guiliano — Sun, 12 Jul 2009 10:21:44 +0000

i have the n97 and my sister has the xperia 1…. so we’re always in competition of which phone is better…and im only 11 !!! :P and my sisters 18

By: Ian

Ian — Fri, 10 Jul 2009 13:35:05 +0000

After owning both the Xperia and the N97, I can confidently say that the N97 beats the X1 hands down.
The X1 is very fiddly and has the poor windows mobile interface. The touch screen is inferior to the N97. On the x1 you can see the screen flex. X1 may have the resolution but video playback is very poor (Full screen) not very smooth – even with the James Bond pre loaded trailer. Playback of recorded videos is painfully jerky. And what’s the point in boasting about the screen res when the camera can’t take pictures that are decent and video won’t play properly on it. The zoom is also no existent on the X1.
I found the build quality terrible on the Sony, I think this was due to it being made by HTC.
Within 4 weeks the paint has started to rub off of the battery cover. I was also a victim of the cracked case which loads of people are experiencing. The x1 gets very hot – to the point where it gets uncomfortable making a call. The volume button stopped working, one of the softkeys stopped working, meaning I couldn’t wipe the device.
Paint rubbed off of the Xperia keyboard. I only have the phone 9 months – Sonys poor customer service didn’t impress me either. I gave the phone away.
The n97 possesses:

Better build quality
Smooth video playback
Smooth playback of recorded content from 5mp camera.
Accelerometer
Digital Compass
Ear proximity sensor (When you move the phone away from your ear the screen light enables to see call time).
Widgets (Better concept that panels)
Better interface than Xperia.
The 32GB of ram + 16GB micro SD
Stereo Speakers (Better quality than the x1 although not as good as the n95)
Larger keyboard (Far easier to type on than the x1)
Decent Text to speech – which reads out messages (You can also hear it unlike MS voice commander on the X1 which has to be purchased properly).
Decent Bluetooth support. (Control of media player not possible on x1 via Bluetooth)
Decent Voice recognition (X1 lacks – TO get it you have to buy MS Voice commander wich doesn’t work properly)
Quicker than the x1
Battery life is much better than x1.
Making a phone call is far easier.
The screen doesn’t have a thick raised frame around it like the x1.
No panels on the n97 (What a relief – Panels served no point whatsoever, apart from a poor attempt to disguise the crap WM interface). This hasn’t changed much since pocket pc.
A broad range of innovative apps that are useful and a lot of them are free.

If I hear people say the words Xperia and power user in the same sentence – I just laugh.
I will never ever own another Sony mobile again.

By: rolanmayor

rolanmayor — Sat, 04 Jul 2009 08:28:12 +0000

N97 leaves Xperia miles away from being greatest phone……..

By: rajat

rajat — Sun, 28 Jun 2009 16:00:01 +0000

n97 is a clear vinner in terms of style and looks.
Widgets are great features.
Connetivity is good .
Memory you can store all your stuff 32 +16gb thats a lot of memory .. What else do u need
Mapa , Ovi store Nokia Messaging client. The list is endless .
Forgot the 5mgp camera with carl z lens
N97 is a clear winner